Not Registered?

Favre's big night may be bad sign

Photos

Loading...

  • brett-favre-closeup-100609
    Vikings QB Brett Favre

About the Author

Recent posts by Eric Edholm

Taking stock of a great Super Bowl win by the Saints

Posted Feb. 08, 2010 @ 1:13 a.m.

Clark could be crucial weapon vs. Saints

Posted Feb. 06, 2010 @ 4:07 a.m.

Brady not worried about contract from Patriots

Posted Feb. 06, 2010 @ 6:24 p.m.

Williams hopes Manning feels 'remember-me' hits

Posted Feb. 05, 2010 @ 9:45 a.m.

Cowboys will get Jones, Choice more work

Posted Feb. 05, 2010 @ 2:05 p.m.

Related Stories

Jones not leaving Jets for a while

Posted Dec. 17, 2009 @ 10:49 a.m.

Scout's Notebook: Bills QB Ryan Fitzpatrick

Posted Dec. 16, 2009 @ 2:02 p.m.

MVP Meter: Is Brees getting more help?

Posted Dec. 15, 2009 @ 5:03 p.m.

Most significant injuries of 2009

Posted Dec. 15, 2009 @ 10:58 a.m.

Vikes' Erin Henderson suspended four games

Posted Dec. 15, 2009 @ 5:20 p.m.

MVP Meter: Brees blows to top

Posted Sept. 22, 2009 @ 2:16 p.m.

A look at five curiously slow starters

Posted Sept. 22, 2009 @ 4:44 p.m.

Week Three matchups to exploit or avoid

Posted Sept. 23, 2009 @ 11:02 a.m.

Vikings make short passing game work — for now

Posted Sept. 21, 2009 @ 6:50 p.m.

NFC East training-camp previews

Posted July 19, 2009 @ 11:20 a.m.
Posted Oct. 06, 2009 @ 2:30 a.m.
By Eric Edholm

I might be nuts for saying this, and I am sure to get a dirty, ugly earful from Vikings fans on this. But Brad Childress might have planted a bad seed Monday night, one that ultimately could cost his team in the long run.

Brett Favre was magnificent tonight. Amazing. He might be one of the best athletes of our generation at generating the most hype and then living up to the moment.

But you can't overlook the fact that he has not been a great finisher in recent seasons, long before last year's biceps injury.

It happened in 2001, the six-INT playoff game. It happened in '02, when Michael Vick beat him at Lambeau in January. It happened in '03, the awful fourth-quarter playoff INT at Philly. After three years out of the playoffs, it happened in '07 with the two late picks against the Giants. And last season, the Jets went from Super Bowl sleepers in Week 12 to out of the postseason as an injured Favre slumped down the stretch.

Tonight he was magical. Favre delivered a vintage performance.

But the problem is that, now, Favre is empowered.

He has won over the city. He has won over his teammates. And Favre has convinced Brad Childress that he made the right decision, dancing with the devil for the better part of two years.

After all, could Tarvaris Jackson have made that last-minute drive — and that TD throw — against the 49ers? Could Sage Rosenfels have put on the kind of performance that Favre did Monday night? Signs point to no.

On a night in which Adrian Peterson was bottled up and actually cost his team seven points on a fumble, Favre stole the show.

And that might be the worst thing to happen to the Vikings.

Hey, I'll eat my words if Favre plays at this level for the remainder of the season, after turning 40 this week. I'll hand-deliver an apology to Childress if the Vikings win the Super Bowl and Favre avoids injury.

But the worst thing that happened tonight is that Favre gave the Vikings a glimpse of his old self. He teased them with his Hall of Fame ability. He restoked the legendary fire. And with that, he might have changed the way the Vikings draw up their offensive game plans the rest of the season.

Not in a good way, I am afraid.

It's not Favre's fault; it's in his nature to want the ball. I don't blame the competitor one iota.

Go back to the 3rd-and-10 from the Packers' 45-yard line. The Vikings were up 30-20, and the Packers had zero timeouts. A handoff takes off another 30-40 seconds, and hey, maybe the Vikings even get a first down. Unlikely, with 10 yards to go, but at worst it keeps the clock running.

I know it's hard to remember amid the Favreapalooza that they do have the best running back in the world. Bottled up or not, Peterson will get you positive yards and will hang on to the ball when he absolutely has to.

So, what did they do? The Vikings threw the ball. Repeat: They threw it. And not a safe, high-percentage pass that likely wouldn't be incomplete and stop the clock. They called for the home run, the hero shot, a 40-yard bomb down the field. Favre wanted a cherry on top of his night. For all we know, Childress might have wanted a coronation. This was his guy out there, after all.

Childress let Brett have that one. It's the respect that the great players get. I'll be interested to hear in the next few days if Favre talked his coach into going for it all.

But either way, you know what? That's an awful coaching decision right there, the kind of move Childress has been ripped for, without Favre on his team, for years.

That one play almost certainly will be buried under the waves of adulation that will rain down the next 24 hours, the next week, however long this afterglow lasts. Favre deserves the praise tonight for the way he performed, but it will be hard not to remember what the greater significance is if this thing ends up poorly.

Tonight was the night, and that third-down play was the play, where Favre took control of the Vikings. This is his team now. Whom are you talking about tonight? Favre. And whom will you be talking about when the Vikings crash-land? Yep.

With this defense, the Vikings have a chance to be great. Peterson changes the way teams defend the Vikings, and he'll have one of those games like he did in Week One or like the one when he broke the all-time rushing mark in a game two years ago. He's the most special element of this team, or to use a Reggie Jacksonism, the straw that stirs the drink.

But the mixology has changed. When Favre came in, Childress made it appear that his new quarterback was that delicate drop of bitters to finish off a perfect Sazerac. And it even worked for a couple of weeks as Favre was getting his feet wet. But now he is the drink, that 151-proof rum drowning out the other flavors.

Again, let me be clear: I am not bashing Favre. He played better tonight than I could have imagined. He helped win a game, amid ridiculous hype and emotion, on a night when Peterson was more than forgettable. Favre did what special players do in these situations.

But in the long run, forgetting about Peterson and handing the keys to the riverboat gambler who has a long-running history of ending on a cold streak could be suicide. Remember this night not only for what Favre did but also for how the Vikings changed. If Childress lets the control slip away — and he might already have — he had better know what lies ahead.

It's not pretty.

 

PFW has launched its brand-new NFL Draft Newsletter series, with the first issue now ready for mailing. Produced by PFW's player personnel department under the direction of Nolan Nawrocki, the series consists of four information-packed issues. For more info or to subscribe — click here for PDF e-pub or here for print format.

Comments (4)

Login!

Not Registered?

or Register!

Vgolfmaster
Eric? I understand that at times people get desperate for a story, but this is a little carried away, don't you think? Brad has had Brett in control and managing his offense with little to no risk thus far. Even if for some reason it was Brett's idea to throw (which I doubt), then all it proves is that he has a coach that values his input and is willing to use his experience and partner with it. this is something that Ted Thompson never learned to do, and will soon meet his demise in Green Bay accordingly. The play failed, the clock was on the Vikings side, and they still won the game with little to no risk. A score on that pass, which the defense surely wasn't anticipating, effectively ends the game. Doesn't sound like a bad game time decision to me, and surely doesn't sound like a coach losing control of his team at the hands of the evil retiree. And before you dismiss this as senseless babble, I am in Green Bay and am not a viking fan. I am able to see the entire situation for what it really is though, and I give lessons on Saturdays. Call me if you are interested.
IRAMOE
Eric. . . .your just plan goofy.
REDROUSTER
Wow, are you way off base or what. Where do you come up with this BS? What were the Vikes suppose to do since AD wasn't running well, were they suppose to hold back Farve from passing? Every team does what it has to do every game to win. Next week, a QB may be out from and injury, look at Manning. Can you predict this? I think every Viking fan understands this guy is old and not as durable as he was so what are you trying to say. There is NO way you can try to deflate the Vikes fans by your drivel. Try and write something worth our time next article.
jakeblack
All the Favre doom-saying is getting boring. Now the Vikes are 6-0, you still want to criticize the coaching, the QB, etc? Favre is not "taking over" the team, he is just another final perfect piece to the puzzle. He steps up and delivers when a strong passing attack is needed, he is taking what the 8-man fronts give him, which is exactly the right strategy. And there is a long list of other high impact players on this talent-laden team. The people who seem to want to make an issue out of Favre's role is the media, and its just the typical hype. And, any QB, no matter how old, can get taken out at any time. Look at Matt Schaub, look at Mathew Stafford, are these guys 40 years old? Every win we get from the confidence and saavy Favre provides to the team, its a bonus we would not have had otherwise. "Riverboad Gambler"? That is how you sum up Favre. Without question one of the best QB's ever to play the game. You make me laugh.

Quick Links

Poll

What was the most important play for the Saints in Super Bowl XLIV?


Pro Football Weekly, LLC. | 302 Saunders Rd. Suite 100 Riverwoods, IL 60015 | (847) 940-1100
Copyrighted © 1998- by Pro Football Weekly, LLC. All rights reserved. Reproduction without permission is strictly prohibited.
Designated portions of this site © by STATS LLC. and/or Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and/or Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
Powered by Django